Backpacker’s Base: Bensonhurst, Brooklyn
A smart choice for budget travelers, Bensonhurst offers an authentic slice of Brooklyn life without the high prices or tourist crowds. This neighborhood gives you a quieter side of New York City, complete with easy transit connections and plenty of local charm that doesn’t rely on trendy hype. You’ll also find several hostels near Bensonhurst, making it a convenient base for exploring both Brooklyn and Manhattan.
In this guide, you’ll discover why Bensonhurst is great for backpackers — from how to get around and the key landmarks to the local amenities, cultural highlights, and timeless travel tips. Think of it as friendly advice from someone who knows the area well.
Landmarks & Local Icons
Here are some fixtures in Bensonhurst that have been around for years and will likely be there when you visit.
- New Utrecht Reformed Church – A building with deep roots. This church dates from the 1600s and stands as a reminder of the district’s long history.
- Magen David Synagogue – A landmark of Bensonhurst’s diverse culture, this synagogue has been a strong community anchor.
- Bensonhurst Park – A pleasant green space by the water on the edge of the neighbourhood. Great for relaxing after a day exploring.
- Milestone Park – A small pocket park with a historical marker, useful for a quiet stroll.
Getting Around
Access to and from the district is solid for someone travelling on a budget and wanting to be mobile.
- Subway lines - The area is served by the D and N trains, making it manageable to reach Manhattan and other Brooklyn spots.
- Bus routes - Several reliable bus lines run through Bensonhurst and connect to major transit hubs.
- Walkable grid - Streets like 18th Avenue and 86th Street are easy to navigate and full of local life.
Reliable Amenities
As a backpacker, you’ll want trustworthy places to eat, drink, rest and explore with minimal fuss. Bensonhurst delivers.
- Food & cafés - Classic bakeries and cafés have long served the area, giving you local flavour without luxury-price tags.
- Green spaces - Parks like Bensonhurst Park offer free, open-air space to chill or read a book. Constant amenity, day after day.
- Residential vibe - Low-rise apartments, small streets and family-run stores mean less tourist hustle and more local rhythm.
Culture & Timeless Tips
Bensonhurst has a rich mix of Italian-American heritage alongside newer communities, giving it layered character. For example, the annual feast of Feast of Santa Rosalia on 18th Avenue has been part of the local tradition for decades.
Tip: Take a slow stroll early in the morning through the residential streets to see everyday life here. Chat with a local baker or grab coffee near 18th Avenue – it’s cheaper and more genuine than many tourist spots.
Why Stay in Bensonhurst
Here’s why Bensonhurst makes sense for budget-travellers and backpackers:
- More affordable - Because it’s less central-tourist, you’ll find better value in accommodation and food.
- Real neighbourhood feel - You’re among residents, not just tourists. You’ll experience the city in a low-key, authentic way.
- Solid access - Great transport links mean you’re still connected to the wider city network.
- Calm base - After big-city days, you’ll appreciate returning to a quieter spot to recharge.
If you’re looking for a true slice of New York without the high prices or tourist crowds, Bensonhurst is a smart choice. This neighborhood blends local charm, historic character, and everyday comfort — from classic eateries and friendly streets to peaceful parks and easy transport connections. For backpackers, it’s a reliable and down-to-earth base that offers authenticity, affordability, and a lasting sense of community.